CFNM
Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register.
Oct 26th, 2014, 12:23am

News: Welcome to our Forum!

Go To CFNM Photos  Board  
Go To CFNM Stories Board  
It's a Naked World! Nude Beaches - Public Nudity
It's a Naked World! Nude Beaches - Public Nudity

Home Home Help Help Search Search Members Members Login Login Register Register

Hey check this out: CFNM Party at CFNM Club





   Sensations For Women
   General
   CFNM Stories and Discussion
(Moderators: g_man, Rick176701, strapman, RevJohnAshcroft, PumpkinEater, hey2004, Superfluous, chaoslord621, Mansterdam, Debbie_RN, ADMIN, JerBear, BBMan, malibug, Lord_Caspen, igorisapud, Brad, Anthony_M, kiwimark, doug444, Roman_Mistress, Woodster, lazarus)
   A Law Case involving Forced CFNM
« Previous topic | Next topic »
Pages: 1  Reply Reply Notify of replies Notify of replies Send Topic Send Topic Print Print
   Author  Topic: A Law Case involving Forced CFNM  (Read 9109 times)
Skyclad
YaBB Newbie
*



I love YaBB

   


Gender: male
Posts: 2
A Law Case involving Forced CFNM
« on: Dec 13th, 2012, 10:50pm »
Quote Quote Modify Modify

I found the following 11th Circuit Court of Appeals case involving (forced) CFNM. The name of the case is Butler v. Sheriff of Palm Beach County, 685 F.3d 1261, C.A.11 (Fla.), 2012. The actual language used by the Court in its decision is in italics. The actual decision is much longer, but it is the facts that are relevant to this website.
 
In one of his ballads, Jim Croce warned that there are four things that you just don't do: “You don't tug on Superman's cape/ You don't spit into the wind/ You don't pull the mask off that old Lone Ranger/ And you don't mess around with Jim.”[ FN 1. Jim Croce, “You Don't Mess Around With Jim” (ABC Records 1972).] He could have added a fifth warning to that list: “And you don't let a pistol-packing mother catch you naked in her daughter's closet.”
 
It all started with a phone call.  Nineteen-year-old Uzuri Collier called Larry Butler, who was of a similar age, and invited him to her house. Butler responded to the invitation the way most young men over the age of consent would have—he went. Once Butler was at Uzuri's house, he and she consented to watch television for a while. Then they consented to do what young couples alone in a house have been consenting to do since the memory of man (and woman) runneth not to the contrary . The record does not disclose how long these two young people had known each other in the dictionary sense, but that afternoon in Uzuri's bedroom they also knew each other in the biblical sense. While doing so, and while clothed in the manner that is customary in such matters, which is to say not at all, they heard someone coming into the house.
 
The record does not tell us how the timing worked out as unfortunately as it did. It may be that the two young people simply lost track of time, which would be understandable given the circumstances. Or it may be that Uzuri's mother, Dorethea Collier, left work early that day. However it happened, Collier came close to catching the couple coupling. So close that when they heard her, Butler had only enough time to dash into the bedroom closet wearing nothing but a look of surprise.
 
Collier was a corrections officer at the Eagle Academy, which is a “boot-camp facility for minors” run by the Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office. She was wearing her uniform and gun belt with pistol and “[u]pon entering the room, she began demanding that Uzuri explain why she was undressed and what she was doing.” While talking with her daughter, Collier took off her utility belt and threw it on the bed. Sometime thereafter—the implication is sooner rather than later—Collier discovered Butler stark naked in her daughter's closet. She yelled at him and punched him one time. Then Collier picked up her utility belt, put it back on, and drew her gun. She told Butler that if he moved or did not follow her commands, she would shoot him.
 
Butler tried to explain that Uzuri had invited him to the house, but Collier insisted that he must have broken in. She had the still-naked Butler turn around, she handcuffed him, and she made him get down on his knees. After staying there “for a prolonged period,” Butler pleaded with Collier that he could not maintain that position any longer. Collier responded by telling him to bend over or she would shoot him. She “made numerous threats against Butler, [telling him] that she would ‘kill him’ if he did not obey her commands.”
 
While still holding Butler at gunpoint, Collier called her husband and told him to come home immediately. After that, she called a supervisor at Eagle Academy and asked what charges she could bring against Butler for entering the house and “engaging in sexual relations with her daughter.” The supervisor told Collier that if Butler had entered without permission he could be charged with trespassing and rape, but that if he had been invited in, she would have to let him go. About this time, Collier's husband arrived at the house, and he “also assaulted Butler.” In what manner, we are not told.
 
Collier continued to hold Butler at gunpoint, threatening to kill him if he did not follow orders. After Collier's husband “inquired further” about the naked man's identity and determined who he was, Butler was allowed to get dressed and leave, although Collier kept the gun pointed at him while he was dressing. One can assume that it did not take Butler long to get dressed and get out, but before he had time to leave Collier “warned him about the consequences of filing charges or even ‘thinking about’ reporting the incident.” She told Butler that if he reported what had happened, she “would submit a report to discredit him and would engage in some ‘creative writing’ if necessary to justify the filing of charges against him for trespassing on the property.” Despite those threats, Butler eventually reported the incident to law enforcement. There is no allegation that Collier responded by submitting a report of her own or by filing trespassing charges against Butler.

 
 
The Court ruled that the “Corrections officer was not acting "under color of state law," for purposes of § 1983 action against county sheriff, when, after discovering a naked young man in her daughter's bedroom closet, she allegedly punched him, held him at gunpoint, handcuffed him, threatened to shoot him if he did not obey her commands, and warned him that if he reported what had happened she would file trespassing charges against him; officer's conduct, or misconduct, was not accomplished because of her status as a corrections officer, but constituted the private actions of an angry mother.”
 
The Appellate Court concluded that “The amended complaint and Butler's briefs leave no doubt that he feels mistreated, and with what appears to be some justification. If the allegations are true, Collier's treatment of Butler was badder than old King Kong and meaner than a junkyard dog. She might even have acted like the meanest hunk of woman anybody had ever seen. Still, the fact that the mistreatment was mean does not mean that the mistreatment was under color of law. Because the alleged mistreatment of Butler was not inflicted under color of law, the district court correctly dismissed his § 1983 claims. Butler will have to seek his remedies under state law and in state court.”
IP Logged
SteveH
YaBB God
*****





   


Gender: male
Posts: 526
Re: A Law Case involving Forced CFNM
« Reply #1 on: Dec 14th, 2012, 7:17am »
Quote Quote Modify Modify

What amazes me is the language of the court - very colorful and a far cry from the very po-faced English that you usually find in the wording of most court decisions (at least in the UK). Is this typical of US judicial decisions? They must be sending their court reporters on Creative Writing 101 courses!   Smiley
IP Logged
SingleDonald
YaBB God
*****



I love YaBB 1G - SP1!

   


Posts: 2079
Re: A Law Case involving Forced CFNM
« Reply #2 on: Dec 14th, 2012, 4:49pm »
Quote Quote Modify Modify

This whole thing gets me sick! How can one assume Mrs. Collier was NOT acting out her role, as a corrections officer? She pointed her gun at him and threatened to kill him, if he didn't comply with her sick wishes! I sure hope that Larry files an additional lawsuit, againds both of Uzuri's parents! I'm also saddened that Uzuri didn't do anything to protect her lover from her parents. I applaud Larry for not being intimidated by the threats made by the girl's mother, against him.
I am a bit confused: The decision was handed down this year, but when did the actual incident take place? I'm sure it wasn't in 1983, which year is mentioned in the article.
In summary, the mother's despicable behavior SHOULD HAVE been sanctioned by the Appellate Court!!
« Last Edit: Dec 14th, 2012, 4:50pm by SingleDonald » IP Logged
jclause2
YaBB Full Member
***



hello world

   


Posts: 112
Re: A Law Case involving Forced CFNM
« Reply #3 on: Dec 14th, 2012, 5:52pm »
Quote Quote Modify Modify

The 1983 was the section number, not the year. The appellate court was not making a ruling (one way or the other) on the claim against the mother, but rather in his claim against Palm Beach County Sheriff's office.
 
His claim was that her actions were done as a representative of the Sheriff's office. The court determined that she was acting on her own and not as a Sheriff's office representative.
 
If there had been a pattern of such behavior amongst sheriff's employees or if someone else in the office helped her or facilitated her actions, his claim may have been valid. Since there wasn't, the court determined that she was acting on her own.
 
The court did not rule against him on his claim against the mother, rather told him that that's the claim he would need to pursue. He likely was attempting to sue the Sheriff's Office since the county has more money than his (ex-) girlfriend's family does (following the deep-pockets theory).
« Last Edit: Dec 14th, 2012, 5:52pm by jclause2 » IP Logged
SingleDonald
YaBB God
*****



I love YaBB 1G - SP1!

   


Posts: 2079
Re: A Law Case involving Forced CFNM
« Reply #4 on: Dec 14th, 2012, 6:17pm »
Quote Quote Modify Modify

jclause2,
 Thanks for the clarification! I now agree with the court's ruling, and hope that Larry Butler ultimately gets justice!!
IP Logged
John_in_Exile
YaBB Senior Member
****



I love YaBB

   


Posts: 315
Re: A Law Case involving Forced CFNM
« Reply #5 on: Dec 15th, 2012, 9:58am »
Quote Quote Modify Modify


Sun-Sentinel – A Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office corrections deputy was arrested Monday for assaulting a man at gunpoint who was having sex with her daughter in the deputy’s Belle Glade home.  Dorethea Collier, 48, was charged with false imprisonment, aggravated assault and battery for the Nov. 2 incident. She was arrested following a review by the State Attorney’s Office, said Sheriff’s Office spokeswoman Teri Barbera.  When Collier arrived home, Larry Butler, 19, of Pahokee, hid in the closet while Collier’s daughter, Uzuri Collier, 20, held her bedroom door shut.  But Dorethea Collier barged in and found her daughter partially clothed and a naked Butler in the closet.  The uniformed deputy punched Butler three or four times and then pointed her gun at him, handcuffed him and ordered him to his knees.  Her daughter begged her not to shoot Butler. Dorethea Collier also threatened to send Butler to jail for raping her daughter.  Uzuri Collier’s father, Michael Collier, 48, then arrived home after his wife called him. He hit his daughter and Butler, who was eventually allowed to get dressed and leave.
 
http://nyc.barstoolsports.com/random-thoughts/does-this-look-like-the-fa ce-of-a-mom-who-would-punch-in-the-headhandcuffput-gun-to-temple-of-guy-she-found-nailing-her-daughter/
IP Logged
Pages: 1  Reply Reply Notify of replies Notify of replies Send Topic Send Topic Print Print

« Previous topic | Next topic »




Videos from CoccoVision:
True Fantasy
Bad Boys of Bourbon Street #4
60 minutes
$19.95
Now that's novel! It's the GUYS flashing instead of the girls! I think they're just collecting more beads so they can get more girls to flash. Only men flashing in this video. LINK TO SAMPLES

ADD TO DVD CART: $19.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $12.95 XVID - or check out
CFNMzone
DVD-1
For the Girls & Dare to Compare
60 minutes
$29.95
CFNM - Clothed Female Naked Male fetish video productions by CFNMzone.com. Three girlfriends have asked a couple of guys to hang out naked with them. The second video is a garden party where guys have been invited to have their equipment assessed. LINK TO SAMPLES

ADD TO DVD CART: $29.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $19.95 XVID - or check out
CFNMzone
DVD-2
Born to Lose & Caught Skinny-Dipping
60 minutes
$29.95
Somehow the guys always lose in strip poker and are at the mercy of the girls. Video 2: Three girls catch some guys swimming in their pool and won't give them back theri clothes until they can check out every square inch of their bodies. LINK TO SAMPLES

ADD TO DVD CART: $29.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $19.95 XVID - or check out
CFNMzone
DVD-4
Paula's Pecker Boys & Ariel's Dick Show
60 minutes
$29.95
A group of clothed girls hang around the pool while more and more naked pool boys come by for attention. Video 2: A garden party where a group of girls commands some naked guys to wank in various ways. LINK TO SAMPLES

ADD TO DVD CART: $29.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $19.95 XVID - or check out
CFNMzone
DVD-5
Shipwrecked & Rent-a-Cop
60 minutes
$29.95
Two girls find a shipwreked guy on the beach and soon make sure he is "feeling better". Video 2: A police officer arrives at a girls' party and shows them his arresting attributes. LINK TO SAMPLES

ADD TO DVD CART: $29.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $19.95 XVID - or check out
CFNMzone
DVD-9
Tickled and Tied & Bare Facts
55 minutes
$29.95
CFNM - Clothed Female Naked Male fetish video productions by CFNMzone. She tied him to her bed as he slept, then invited her girlfriends over. Video 2: Two athletes are surprised to find several female reporters in their locker room, looking for a scoop. LINK TO SAMPLES

ADD TO DVD CART: $29.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $19.95 XVID - or check out
CFNMzone
DVD-10
Academy for Girls & Personal Trainer
50 minutes
$29.95
CFNM - Clothed Female Naked Male fetish video productions by CFNMzone. The girls' sex class has brought in a live male specimen to be examined. Video 2: This personal trainer required him to work out nude so she can better assess his physical progress. LINK TO SAMPLES

ADD TO DVD CART: $29.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $19.95 XVID - or check out
CFNMzone
DVD-12
2006 CFNM Games & Strip or Consequences
50 minutes
$29.95
CFNM - Clothed Female Naked Male fetish video productions by CFNMzone. In the spirit of the fact that the original Olympics were done in the nude. Video 2: This lucky guy is the girls personal plaything. LINK TO SAMPLES

ADD TO DVD CART: $29.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $19.95 XVID - or check out
CFNMzone
DVD-13
St. Patricks Day Party & Paula's Pecker Boy Audition
50 minutes
$29.95
CFNM - Clothed Female Naked Male fetish video productions by CFNMzone. The boys wear green hats and nothing else. Video 2: The boys show the girls everything they've got. LINK TO SAMPLES

ADD TO DVD CART: $29.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $19.95 XVID - or check out
CFNMzone
DVD-15
Who's Fooling Who & Tied/Tickled II
68 minutes
$29.95
CFNM - Clothed Female Naked Male fetish video productions by CFNMzone. Art School confidential and a tickle fest. LINK TO SAMPLES

ADD TO DVD CART: $29.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $19.95 XVID - or check out
CFNMzone
DVD-16
My Nutty Boyfriend & Rich Girl Blues
42 minutes
$29.95
CFNM - Clothed Female Naked Male fetish video productions by CFNMzone. A surprise awakening for this guy, and rich girls get themselves some boy toys. LINK TO SAMPLES

ADD TO DVD CART: $29.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $19.95 XVID - or check out
CFNMzone
DVD-18
Training Day & Porn for Women
70 minutes
$29.95
CFNM - Clothed Female Naked Male fetish video productions by CFNMzone. Boys just need some training, that's all. And the girls get out their cameras! LINK TO SAMPLES

ADD TO DVD CART: $29.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $19.95 XVID - or check out
CFNMzone
DVD-19
The Gift & Happy Endings
70 minutes
$29.95
CFNM - Clothed Female Naked Male fetish video productions by CFNMzone. When you TAKE something is it still a gift? Why do pool cleaners always get all the fun? LINK TO SAMPLES

ADD TO DVD CART: $29.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $19.95 XVID - or check out
Vrod-100's
The Naked Mile
(Public Nudity)
100 minutes
$29.95
The world's biggest expression of CFNM ever. 8 out of 10 runners were male college students and girls came out in droves to watch this spectacle! Shot with six cameras, with over 1000 runners, this footage has never been seen before. Tightly edited with non-stop action.
vidcap samples
ADD TO DVD CART: $29.95 DVD - or check out
ADD TO MPEG CART: $19.95 XVID - or check out


It's a Naked World! Nude Beaches - Public Nudity
It's a Naked World! Nude Beaches - Public Nudity



Powered by YaBB 3 Gold - SP 2.3!
Forum software copyright © 2000-2004 Yet another Bulletin Board